A personal view of Australian and International Politics

Contemporary politics, local and international current affairs, science and extracts from the Queensland Newspaper "THE WORKER" documenting the proud history of the Labour Movement. Truth never damages a cause that is just ~ MAHATMA GANDHI

Friday, 16 June 2017

Does our political system still work? Finkel test will provide the answer

Extract from The Guardian

Energy

Katharine Murphy
Neither the Coalition nor Labor has the perfect solution for a pressing energy problem that is affecting everyone in the country

Treasurer Scott Morrison with a lump of coal
Treasurer Scott Morrison’s coal antics earned some laughs in parliament in February, but the energy debate has turned far more serious. Photograph: Mick Tsikas/AAP

Contact author
Friday 16 June 2017 14.47 AEST Last modified on Friday 16 June 2017 15.27 AEST

The most interesting thing about Malcolm Turnbull’s now globally shared speech to the mid-winter ball was not the Trump parody, fun as it was, but its tone. It revealed something of the prime minister’s current mood.
Delivered in the middle of a difficult week, when Turnbull was once again being publicly defied by the man he replaced and by a bunch of mouthy colleagues who always knew best andweren’t inclined to yield, Turnbull was sardonic and self-parodying, a little bit devil-may-care, a lot defiant.
The outing wasn’t a lapse or a brain snap, it was entirely, ruthlessly, focused.
If you had to chart a prime ministerial mood between fight or flight, between defiance and deference, you would say Turnbull is limbering up with the boxing gloves on. It was like he said to the room: the colleagues, journalists, suits, log rollers – just because you don’t know what my plan is, doesn’t mean I don’t have one.
Defiance in politics can be a lionised quality among professional myth makers, chroniclers who are paid-up members of the Great Men of History Club, where inspired prime ministers prevail by singular acts of will.
But it doesn’t always deliver the desired result, and certainly not in contemporary politics, which has an animating current of permanent contest.
Relentlessly pushing forward in presidential mode carried a high personal price for Turnbull in 2009, when Tony Abbott outflanked him in the last internal fight about climate policy.
The current fight inside the Coalition about the Finkel review isn’t a perfect facsimile of 2009 – in fact, several things are fundamentally different. But one question does linger, and it frames the whole enterprise. Has the prime minister learned how to bring detractors and wreckers to heel, without self-immolation?

 The Finkel review - Politics over science

As interesting as this question is, bigger ones loom in the energy debate, which from my perch is the most consequential conversation we are going to have in Australian politics this year.
The challenge imposed by the Finkel review is more substantial than whether Australia should adopt a clean energy target to deliver policy certainty and help reduce carbon pollution.
I’ve said before it is a litmus test of whether our political system still works.
The case for action is obvious. Australia needs an energy grid that functions and we need to reduce carbon emissions. No ifs, buts or maybes – for any responsible government, that’s the task.
But climate policy remains a form of political kryptonite. Rational action must always run the gauntlet of, first, the blowhards of the reactionary, hate-spewing media, intent on substituting culture war for fact and wrapping their thuggishness in a cloak of victimhood; and, second, the lingering fog of special interests.
Past dynamics have poisoned this debate so comprehensively that we are now reduced to squabbling over a third or fourth best policy option to solve a pressing problem that directly affects every person in the country.
That’s what a clean energy target is. It’s not a magic bullet, or a perfect solution that has fallen, fortuitously, from the sky.
In fact as policy goes, it’s pretty suboptimal.
It’s what you get when you reach a policy nadir so shameful that even the immaculately suited short-termists, who worked to sink Labor’s carbon price a couple of years ago, are too embarrassed to own their own misjudgment, and are largely lining up on the side of action.
So, as both contributor to the sum of these parts, and inheritor of the consequences, the Coalition has to work out whether it can set aside its taste for lethal factionalism, for jostling, preening and indulging its own operatic yet entirely dull and predictable feelpinions – and remember that the voting public wants answers.
Not more failure. Answers.
And apart from the challenge of not behaving like a querulous rabble at taxpayers’ expense, in practical terms the government has also got to work out how it squares its own circles.
As the Victorian Liberal Russell Broadbent asked, not unreasonably, during the special party room meeting this week – how is it that we have spent the last six months railing against the evils of renewable energy targets and are now proposing one as the answer to the energy policy problem?
As Homer Simpson might say, d’oh!
Assuming the government can emerge with a workable energy policy proposal despite the dogged internal unreason – let’s call that The Big If – Labor then has to decide whether to sign on.
Let’s boil this down to the simplest, most clear-eyed assessment on current information. It’s clear coal will have to be in the scheme if it is to clear the Coalition party room. That means a baseline somewhere north of 700kg of CO2 per megawatt hour.
Labor has approached the Finkel process offering bipartisanship, and probably even meaning it at some level, but the opposition has also preemptively drawn the coal line.
Labor’s climate change spokesman, Mark Butler, makes the entirely correct point that a clean energy target that includes coal is not a clean energy target.
But in the real world, it’s clear that no one wants to build a new “clean” coal plant, given the risk of it being a stranded asset. Governments could, of course, intervene if they were inclined to make a deeply stupid investment more attractive, but the economics of coal investment won’t shift decisively as a consequence of coal-fired power operators being eligible for a small proportion of certificates under a clean energy target.
With that in mind, hard heads in Labor will say sign on, because we have to hold coal seats ourselves at the next election, we are only really talking about theoretical coal, and we can also reserve the right to adjust the scheme in government.
But that won’t be the universal view in the opposition.
For MPs defending seats targeted by the Greens, defending support for a clean energy target with coal in the mix is a pretty tough proposition.
Labor has been trying to hover at a point in its own climate policy deliberations where it can sound negative about coal without totally abandoning coal.

But at some point that artful levitation will have to end – and clear lines will have to be drawn.
Posted by The Worker at 7:32:00 pm
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to TwitterShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest

No comments:

Post a Comment

Newer Post Older Post Home
Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

About Me

My photo
The Worker
I was inspired to start this when I discovered old editions of "The Worker". "The Worker" was first published in March 1890, it was the Journal of the Associated Workers of Queensland. It was a Political Newspaper for the Labour Movement. The first Editor was William "Billy" Lane who strongly supported the iconic Shearers' Strike in 1891. He planted the seed of New Unionism in Queensland with the motto “that men should organise for the good they can do and not the benefits they hope to obtain,” he also started a Socialist colony in Paraguay. Because of the right-wing bias in some sections of the Australian media, I feel compelled to counter their negative and one-sided version of events. The disgraceful conduct of the Murdoch owned Newspapers in the 2013 Federal Election towards the Labor Party shows how unrepresentative some of the Australian media has become.
View my complete profile

Subscribe

Translate

From little things big things grow

Loading...

Dr. James E. Hansen explains Climate Change

Loading...

Billy Bragg

Loading...

Dr. David Suzuki

Loading...

Stephen Hawking and Carl Sagan

Loading...

Siding Spring Observatory

Loading...

The SKA (Square-Kilometre Array)

Loading...

Universal Basic Income

Loading...

Saturday Night Live Trump Satire

Loading...

Search This Blog

Popular Posts

  • Facebook boss Mark Zuckerberg says his own data was shared with Cambridge Analytica
    Extract from  ABC News Updated 14 minutes ago . ...
  • The Guardian view on Antarctica: the worrying retreat of the ice
    Extract from  The Guardian Climate change Opinion Editorial The only thing more frighte...
  • Liberal leadership: Malcolm Turnbull tells Tony Abbott he will challenge
    Extract from  ABC News By political reporter Anna Henderson Updated 21 minutes ago ...
  • Facebook admits your data has probably been scraped by 'malicious actors'
    Extract from  ABC News Updated about 4 hours ago ...
  • Facebook says up to 87m people affected in Cambridge Analytica data-mining scandal
    Extract from  ABC News Updated 9 minutes ago ...
  • Facebook data breach: Aussies find out if they were affected by Cambridge Analytica access
    Extract from  ABC News By science, technology and environment reporter Michael Slezak Updated yesterday at...

Links

  • Australian Council of Trade Unions
  • Australian Labor Party
  • Queensland Council of Unions
  • ALP Queensland
  • Whitlam Institute
  • Chifley Research Centre
  • Labor Herald
  • John Curtin Prime Ministerial Library
  • The CSIRO Climate Science Centre
  • Tim Flannery ~ Australian Climate Council
  • Dr. James E. Hansen explains Climate Change
  • Solar Council
  • David Suzuki Foundation
  • The Environment Time capsule
  • Solar Citizen
  • Cape Grim Greenhouse Gas Data
  • The Jane Goodall Institute Australia
  • Alan Alda Center for Communicating Science
  • RenewEconomy
  • Basic income Earth Network
  • Skeptical Science
  • Lucinda's Song and Dance

Blog Archive

  • ►  2018 (312)
    • ►  April (23)
    • ►  March (127)
    • ►  February (94)
    • ►  January (68)
  • ▼  2017 (2094)
    • ►  December (70)
    • ►  November (97)
    • ►  October (109)
    • ►  September (123)
    • ►  August (161)
    • ►  July (217)
    • ▼  June (201)
      • No more business as usual: the corporates stepping...
      • U.S. Senator Elizabeth Warren
      • Sony to start making records again 30 years after ...
      • Merkel to put climate change at centre of G20 talk...
      • The iPhone is the crack cocaine of technology. Don...
      • Trump loves attacking women's looks. And America r...
      • Trump targets Morning Joe co-hosts in latest Twitt...
      • Farmers join fight against Adani coalmine over env...
      • Reserve Bank boss Philip Lowe urges workers to pus...
      • We must draw attention to the far right. Not to do...
      • Banks should disclose lending to companies with ca...
      • Why do politicians get away with peddling porkies ...
      • World has three years left to stop dangerous clima...
      • A million bottles a minute: world's plastic binge ...
      • Antarctica's ice-free areas to increase by up to a...
      • Astronomers discover orbiting supermassive black h...
      • World according to Pyne exposes Turnbull governmen...
      • Late-night hosts blast GOP healthcare bill as 'com...
      • EPA seeks to scrap rule protecting drinking water ...
      • Bill Shorten pledges to restore cuts to Sunday pen...
      • Tony Abbott trumpets conservative manifesto: 'We n...
      • Climate scientists reveal their fears for the futu...
      • Dinosaur discovery in Winton could hold key to sau...
      • Most Australians want renewables to be primary ene...
      • Malcolm Turnbull be warned: the young are coming
      • Theresa May and the Holy Grail
      • Murray-Darling plan doomed to fail unless more wat...
      • Great Barrier Reef 'too big to fail' at $56b, Delo...
      • Shields and Brooks on the Senate health care bill ...
      • New Orleans mayor: US climate change policy cannot...
      • From heatwaves to hurricanes, floods to famine: se...
      • Trumpcare is like a vampire, set on sinking its te...
      • Burned feet, parched throats: Arizona homeless des...
      • Melting and cracking – is Antarctica falling apart...
      • We need to talk about Finkel (and Adani) - Austral...
      • Portugal forest fires under control after more tha...
      • Hawaii's largest homeless camp: rock bottom or a m...
      • Adani mine 'not a positive thing for Australia', L...
      • Housing 'crisis' looms for older Australians retir...
      • 'Ocean Elders' urge Malcolm Turnbull to reject Ada...
      • Disability advocates slam Pauline Hanson's 'bigote...
      • Is the American dream really dead?
      • Ivanka Trump shoes slated for production at China ...
      • One-third of preschoolers own smartphones or table...
      • Trump presidency gives Australians a negative view...
      • Ten years ago Turnbull called out Peter Garrett on...
      • Australia warned it has radically underestimated c...
      • Global warming brews big trouble in coffee birthpl...
      • Reasons to be cheerful, despite Trump withdrawing ...
      • One Nation confirms it will vote against clean ene...
      • Nationals' push for coal-fired power leaves voters...
      • Why do electricity prices keep going up?
      • 'We're sort of her mum': behind the scenes at Sydn...
      • Victories against Trump are mounting. Here's how w...
      • Not sensible, logical or needs-based: a tale of th...
      • Land clearing rates in Queensland on par with Braz...
      • Why you're about to pay through the nose for power...
      • How Australia's climate policies came to be poison...
      • Donald Trump releases financial disclosure about h...
      • Dairy farmers' daughters milking social media to p...
      • Koalas being trampled by livestock amid habitat lo...
      • Shields and Brooks on Trump’s response to Russia p...
      • Leonard Cohen: Montreal remembers 'local legend' w...
      • Plastic polluted Arctic islands are dumping ground...
      • South Australia to audit Adelaide buildings for fl...
      • Dakota pipeline protesters won a small victory in ...
      • Our politicians show an alarming ignorance of the ...
      • Donald Trump and Rupert Murdoch: inside the billio...
      • Trump admits for first time 'I am being investigat...
      • Donald Trump appears to confirm he is under invest...
      • Does our political system still work? Finkel test ...
      • Battery storage: How it could solve our energy pro...
      • 'Southern-fried snoozefest': late-night hosts on S...
      • Donald Trump under investigation for potential obs...
      • Marine expert warns of climate emergency as fish a...
      • George Christensen signals he won’t vote for Finke...
      • Next time you read your increased power bill, blam...
      • Late-night hosts on Trump's tenure: 'No matter how...
      • Climate change study in Canada's Hudson Bay thwart...
      • Push for Adani to appear before Senate inquiry int...
      • Universal basic income could greatly improve worke...
      • Telstra confirms 1,400 jobs to go in Australia
      • Finkel's target boosts coal industry and does litt...
      • Coal dinosaurs arguing against the Finkel review c...
      • Global demand for coal falls in 2016 for second ye...
      • 'Too early to say' if Coalition will back clean en...
      • Finkel review: Tony Abbott and Craig Laundy clash ...
      • Revealed: reality of life working in an Ivanka Tru...
      • Battery storage and rooftop solar could mean new l...
      • 'Thank you for the blessing': cabinet takes turns ...
      • India has enough coal without Adani mine, yet must...
      • Trump's first Cabinet meeting panned as 'bizarre',...
      • Anti-government demonstrations in Russia – in pict...
      • The fight against climate change: four cities lead...
      • Alan Finkel: 'it would be surprising' if ministers...
      • US opts out of G7 pledge stating Paris climate acc...
      • Queensland budget: Funding announced for new adole...
      • Tony Abbott fears Finkel's clean energy target cou...
      • Trump survived James Comey's testimony, but the fa...
      • Donald Trump's state visit to Britain put on hold
    • ►  May (223)
    • ►  April (170)
    • ►  March (243)
    • ►  February (302)
    • ►  January (178)
  • ►  2016 (1016)
    • ►  December (165)
    • ►  November (163)
    • ►  October (103)
    • ►  September (109)
    • ►  August (66)
    • ►  July (44)
    • ►  June (57)
    • ►  May (68)
    • ►  April (61)
    • ►  March (74)
    • ►  February (50)
    • ►  January (56)
  • ►  2015 (874)
    • ►  December (72)
    • ►  November (69)
    • ►  October (73)
    • ►  September (109)
    • ►  August (71)
    • ►  July (104)
    • ►  June (102)
    • ►  May (80)
    • ►  April (44)
    • ►  March (51)
    • ►  February (32)
    • ►  January (67)
  • ►  2014 (1023)
    • ►  December (65)
    • ►  November (88)
    • ►  October (104)
    • ►  September (91)
    • ►  August (73)
    • ►  July (60)
    • ►  June (87)
    • ►  May (120)
    • ►  April (77)
    • ►  March (128)
    • ►  February (67)
    • ►  January (63)
  • ►  2013 (733)
    • ►  December (50)
    • ►  November (70)
    • ►  October (52)
    • ►  September (49)
    • ►  August (52)
    • ►  July (83)
    • ►  June (116)
    • ►  May (91)
    • ►  April (45)
    • ►  March (36)
    • ►  February (45)
    • ►  January (44)
  • ►  2012 (138)
    • ►  December (20)
    • ►  November (33)
    • ►  October (43)
    • ►  September (24)
    • ►  August (18)
Simple theme. Powered by Blogger.