A personal view of Australian and International Politics

Contemporary politics, local and international current affairs, science and extracts from the Queensland Newspaper "THE WORKER" documenting the proud history of the Labour Movement. Truth never damages a cause that is just ~ MAHATMA GANDHI

Tuesday, 11 July 2017

No wonder the government tries to hide its emissions reports. They stink

Extract from The Guardian

Greenhouse gas emissions
Grogonomics

Greg Jericho
As every greenhouse gas emissions report since June 2014 has shown, the end of the carbon price has led to an increase in emissions. What’s the plan, prime minister?

Emissions from a coal fired power station in the Latrobe Valley, Victoria, Australia
‘Whatever else you want to say about the Direct Action plan of the government, it has utterly failed to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.’ Photograph: Ashley Cooper/Getty Images

Contact author
Tuesday 11 July 2017 04.00 AEST Last modified on Tuesday 11 July 2017 06.54 AEST


Last Friday, the Australian government finally released the latest greenhouse gas emissions report, showing emissions have risen in the past year. When excluding emissions from land use, 2016 saw Australia release a record level of CO2 into the atmosphere. It confirms the failure of the government’s environmental policy at a time when electricity prices – despite the absence of a carbon price – continue to rise at levels above inflation.
The government has a history of being scared to release the greenhouse gas reports. Last year it released the March 2016 and June 2016 reports on the Thursday before Christmas – not exactly peak viewing time. It also meant the March report was released nine months after the March quarter had actually finished.
And once again the government held off releasing the latest report. But in a level of coincidence equal to that of Bill Heslop running into Deirdre Chambers in the Porpoise Split Chinese restaurant, on the day that the Australian Conservation Foundation released FOI documents showing that the government had been sitting on the report for more than a month, the government released the latest report.
And in an effort that rather stretches the meaning of “quarterly”, the government “incorporated” the September quarter figures into the December report.
It says something about how poorly this government values the issue of climate change that over a month ago we had the figures on the entire production that occurred in Australia during the first three months of this year, and yet here we are in July and we still only know the level of greenhouse gas emissions up to December last year.
The figures in the report quickly made it obvious why the government has held off releasing them. They stink. And as every report since June 2014 has shown, the end of the carbon price has led to an increase in emissions.
The poor departmental officials try to paint a happy picture.
The release leads with the line that “total emissions for Australia for the year to December 2016 (including Land Use, Land Use Change and Forestry) are estimated to be 543.3 Mt CO2-e.” They note that this is 2.0% below emissions in 2000, and 10.2% below emissions in 2005. Oddly, they don’t note that is it 1.0% above the emissions in 2015.
The inclusion of land use, land use change and forestry is a fairly dodgy measure.
As Lenore Taylor and Graham Readfern have reported, the inclusion of that measure in the Kyoto protocol in 1997 was essentially an “Australia clause” – because then environment minister Senator Robert Hill pushed for it to be counted as it allowed us to take advantage of changes to land clearing after 1990.
But the benefits from those changes have finished (though pointedly the Paris agreement from 2005 still includes them):
Excluding the “LULUCF” means focusing on actual greenhouse gas emissions rather than including the reductions in emissions from planting trees or in agreeing not to clear land.
But the news on emissions excluding LULUCF is less able to be painted in a positive light. In December, they increased 0.4% relative to September and were up 1.4% compared to December 2015.
While looking at individual quarters is interesting, a better picture is gained by looking at the sum of emissions over a 12-month period. And here we see that 2016 recorded a record level of emissions:
The biggest contributor to our emissions is the electricity sector – around 35% of all emissions:
But in 2016 the biggest increase to emissions came from “stationary energy” – that is emissions that come via combustion fuels used in industry – and fugitive emissions which occur during the production, processing, transport, storage, transmission and distribution of fossil fuels:
The electricity sector however is the most important, not only because it is the biggest, but also because it is the sector for which renewable energy is most viable. In this sector, the impact of the carbon price and its removal is particularly stark:
Whatever else you want to say about the Direct Action plan of the government, it has utterly failed to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.
That’s a problem for the government because even on its “business as usual” projections, it expects electricity emissions to fall sharply in the next few years:
And those business as usual projections would see total emissions by 2030 at just 0.5% below 2005 levels, rather than the 26%-28% lower level we are aiming to achieve under the Paris agreement:
And this is where the problem for the government really hits.
The Finkel Review recommends implementing a clean energy target that would lead to a 28% reduction in emissions from electricity by 2030. But that alone would not get Australia’s total greenhouse gas emissions down to the 26% target.
Were electricity emissions to fall 28% and the rest of the economy continue on a business as usual cases, our total emissions would only fall by around 8% below 2005 levels – and the biggest contributor would be counting the falls in land use and land use change that occurred from 2005-2013.
If you excluded the LULUCF category, our emissions would have actually risen by 3%:
Clearly a 28% cut to electricity emissions alone is not enough. But to achieve cuts in other sectors of the economy there would need to be not just a clean energy target or an emissions intensity scheme which targets the electricity sector, but an economy-wide carbon price.
Right now the government won’t even commit to a clean energy target, even though the Finkel Review found that it would lead to lower electricity prices as well as lower emissions compared to business as usual.
A report by energy analysis firm RepuTex this week also showed that that a more ambitious target of 45% below 2005 levels would see even lower electricity prices by 2030 due to the increase in renewable energy production and a lower reliance on gas – which is the main cause of a 10% rise in electricity prices in Sydney over the past year and a 7.7% rise in Melbourne.
At some point, this government will have to realise that if it wants lower electricity prices the best way to go about is to also lower greenhouse gas emissions. Because its currently policy is doing neither.
Posted by The Worker at 7:53:00 am
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to TwitterShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest

No comments:

Post a Comment

Newer Post Older Post Home
Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

About Me

My photo
The Worker
I was inspired to start this when I discovered old editions of "The Worker". "The Worker" was first published in March 1890, it was the Journal of the Associated Workers of Queensland. It was a Political Newspaper for the Labour Movement. The first Editor was William "Billy" Lane who strongly supported the iconic Shearers' Strike in 1891. He planted the seed of New Unionism in Queensland with the motto “that men should organise for the good they can do and not the benefits they hope to obtain,” he also started a Socialist colony in Paraguay. Because of the right-wing bias in some sections of the Australian media, I feel compelled to counter their negative and one-sided version of events. The disgraceful conduct of the Murdoch owned Newspapers in the 2013 Federal Election towards the Labor Party shows how unrepresentative some of the Australian media has become.
View my complete profile

Subscribe

Translate

From little things big things grow

Loading...

Dr. James E. Hansen explains Climate Change

Loading...

Billy Bragg

Loading...

Dr. David Suzuki

Loading...

Stephen Hawking and Carl Sagan

Loading...

Siding Spring Observatory

Loading...

The SKA (Square-Kilometre Array)

Loading...

Universal Basic Income

Loading...

Saturday Night Live Trump Satire

Loading...

Search This Blog

Popular Posts

  • Facebook boss Mark Zuckerberg says his own data was shared with Cambridge Analytica
    Extract from  ABC News Updated 14 minutes ago . ...
  • The Guardian view on Antarctica: the worrying retreat of the ice
    Extract from  The Guardian Climate change Opinion Editorial The only thing more frighte...
  • Liberal leadership: Malcolm Turnbull tells Tony Abbott he will challenge
    Extract from  ABC News By political reporter Anna Henderson Updated 21 minutes ago ...
  • Facebook admits your data has probably been scraped by 'malicious actors'
    Extract from  ABC News Updated about 4 hours ago ...
  • Facebook says up to 87m people affected in Cambridge Analytica data-mining scandal
    Extract from  ABC News Updated 9 minutes ago ...
  • Facebook data breach: Aussies find out if they were affected by Cambridge Analytica access
    Extract from  ABC News By science, technology and environment reporter Michael Slezak Updated yesterday at...

Links

  • Australian Council of Trade Unions
  • Australian Labor Party
  • Queensland Council of Unions
  • ALP Queensland
  • Whitlam Institute
  • Chifley Research Centre
  • Labor Herald
  • John Curtin Prime Ministerial Library
  • The CSIRO Climate Science Centre
  • Tim Flannery ~ Australian Climate Council
  • Dr. James E. Hansen explains Climate Change
  • Solar Council
  • David Suzuki Foundation
  • The Environment Time capsule
  • Solar Citizen
  • Cape Grim Greenhouse Gas Data
  • The Jane Goodall Institute Australia
  • Alan Alda Center for Communicating Science
  • RenewEconomy
  • Basic income Earth Network
  • Skeptical Science
  • Lucinda's Song and Dance

Blog Archive

  • ►  2018 (312)
    • ►  April (23)
    • ►  March (127)
    • ►  February (94)
    • ►  January (68)
  • ▼  2017 (2094)
    • ►  December (70)
    • ►  November (97)
    • ►  October (109)
    • ►  September (123)
    • ►  August (161)
    • ▼  July (217)
      • Al Gore: 'The rich have subverted all reason'
      • The Day After, ABC News debate 1983 - Nuclear War
      • US flies B-1B bombers over Korean peninsula after ...
      • Court fight to release secret 'palace' letters abo...
      • 'The president is a pyromaniac': the week Trump se...
      • Premier Annastacia Palaszczuk claims underdog stat...
      • Reince Priebus ousted amid tumultuous days for Don...
      • North Korean missile test proves US is well within...
      • It’s time to reduce inequality rather than debatin...
      • Shields and Brooks on Reince Priebus’ exit, GOP he...
      • Does the global terrorism threat, rising inequalit...
      • Molecule found in Titan's atmosphere may form cell...
      • Albert Namatjira: vivid watercolours of Australian...
      • Late-night hosts on Scaramucci's rant: 'That’s wha...
      • The Murray-Darling basin scandal: a symptom of how...
      • With Trump it’s time to go beyond mere disgust
      • The best way to prepare for the future of work? Jo...
      • Malcolm Roberts citizenship explainer: one nation ...
      • Working people are over hearing neoliberalism is g...
      • Renewables to replace gas as SA's main electricity...
      • Inequality is real - and guess what? The electorat...
      • We Have Online Ancestry Databases Suggesting A One...
      • One Nation's Malcolm Roberts 'choosing to believe ...
      • Queensland electric car 'super highway' announced,...
      • New 'experimental' data shows an increase in peopl...
      • NBN: How to check if your plan is delivering speed...
      • Growing number of Australians juggling multiple jo...
      • Murray-Darling basin: allegations of water theft s...
      • Unapproved land clearing an unfolding environmenta...
      • Religious leaders occupy environment minister's of...
      • Bill Shorten's inequality pitch has rustled the ji...
      • Senate issues subpoena to Paul Manafort for testim...
      • Murray-Darling Basin Plan: Irrigation lobbyists of...
      • Jared Kushner's explanations on Russia reveal a ma...
      • Moon wetter than previously thought, raising new m...
      • China's state media warns of further warship deplo...
      • Sunshine Coast Council stays true to its name by o...
      • The power and passion of union boss Sally McManus
      • Bill Shorten says Labor will 'create one tax syste...
      • Drop in wind energy costs adds pressure for govern...
      • Trump not convinced Russian meddling took place, c...
      • Donald Trump promised he'd save jobs at Carrier, n...
      • Donald Trump fires off tweets on Russia probe, cla...
      • Shields and Brooks on Spicer stepping down, GOP he...
      • Alan Tudge waves his wand – and turns welfare deba...
      • The Late Show with Stephen Colbert - Donald Trump ...
      • Five places that mark Australia's extreme geologic...
      • Pepsico, Unilever and NestlĂ© accused of complicity...
      • Australia's marine parks face cuts to protected ar...
      • Six months into America's nightmare, how likely is...
      • Sean Spicer resigns as Trump press secretary after...
      • Chinese Navy spy ship rattles Talisman Sabre war g...
      • Punishing people for poverty won't make the comple...
      • Report that Trump considering pardons for family a...
      • Jeff Sessions says he'll keep job 'as long as appr...
      • Donald Trump reportedly exploring ways to hamper R...
      • Malcolm Turnbull warns borrowers of interest rate ...
      • Building new coal-fired power stations should be m...
      • Dirty coal to dirty politics: everything is connec...
      • Nothing about the Trump presidency is normal. Keep...
      • Australia's social housing stock one-sixth empty w...
      • Bill Shorten says inequality threatens Australia's...
      • Alvey fishing reel company to close after almost 1...
      • We Hold These Truths to be Self-Evident - About Cl...
      • Australian dig finds evidence of Aboriginal habita...
      • Past extinctions point to a current and future bio...
      • Fresh legal challenge looms over Adani mine risk t...
      • Young People's Burden: The Science, Climate Change...
      • Matt Canavan on Q&A: exporting Adani coal does not...
      • Five park rangers killed in DRC in tragic weekend ...
      • Queensland must wean itself off coal, says Jackie ...
      • Bill Shorten says Labor willing to pass Finkel leg...
      • The Long Goodbye - Coal, Coral and Australia's Cli...
      • Healthcare study ranks Australia second best in de...
      • Barry McGuire and John York - Eve of Destruction 2...
      • Billy Bragg - The Times They Are A-Changing Back
      • 'This has been my life for past six years': on the...
      • Australian cricket's pay dispute is a wonderful ad...
      • Home ownership in Australia in decline for three d...
      • Trump is ushering in a dark new conservatism
      • The world we have bequeathed to our children feels...
      • Government’s letter to conservation groups has omi...
      • Trump regrets 'bizarre mistake' of Paris climate p...
      • Saibai islanders celebrate new $24.5m seawall to f...
      • Shields and Brooks on fallout from Donald Trump Jr...
      • Electric cars, mass extinction, and a swimming ele...
      • Trump conflict of interest concerns over links wit...
      • Clean energy target: how the states might make it ...
      • The cynical and dishonest denial of climate change...
      • Facts matter, but stories can persuade us to chang...
      • Ex-Soviet counter-intelligence officer says he att...
      • Welfare recipients in 'some of Australia's poorest...
      • Are we sleepwalking to World War III?
      • Push for 'Australian values' education to counter ...
      • Woolworths and Coles to phase out single-use plast...
      • States move towards clean energy, but Frydenberg s...
      • State energy ministers threaten to lock Federal Go...
      • North Korean nuclear ambitions put long-time ally ...
      • Juno and the Great Red Spot: First NASA images fro...
      • Adani mine 'spinning the roulette wheel' on surviv...
    • ►  June (201)
    • ►  May (223)
    • ►  April (170)
    • ►  March (243)
    • ►  February (302)
    • ►  January (178)
  • ►  2016 (1016)
    • ►  December (165)
    • ►  November (163)
    • ►  October (103)
    • ►  September (109)
    • ►  August (66)
    • ►  July (44)
    • ►  June (57)
    • ►  May (68)
    • ►  April (61)
    • ►  March (74)
    • ►  February (50)
    • ►  January (56)
  • ►  2015 (874)
    • ►  December (72)
    • ►  November (69)
    • ►  October (73)
    • ►  September (109)
    • ►  August (71)
    • ►  July (104)
    • ►  June (102)
    • ►  May (80)
    • ►  April (44)
    • ►  March (51)
    • ►  February (32)
    • ►  January (67)
  • ►  2014 (1023)
    • ►  December (65)
    • ►  November (88)
    • ►  October (104)
    • ►  September (91)
    • ►  August (73)
    • ►  July (60)
    • ►  June (87)
    • ►  May (120)
    • ►  April (77)
    • ►  March (128)
    • ►  February (67)
    • ►  January (63)
  • ►  2013 (733)
    • ►  December (50)
    • ►  November (70)
    • ►  October (52)
    • ►  September (49)
    • ►  August (52)
    • ►  July (83)
    • ►  June (116)
    • ►  May (91)
    • ►  April (45)
    • ►  March (36)
    • ►  February (45)
    • ►  January (44)
  • ►  2012 (138)
    • ►  December (20)
    • ►  November (33)
    • ►  October (43)
    • ►  September (24)
    • ►  August (18)
Simple theme. Powered by Blogger.