Saturday 15 July 2023

Why are Hollywood actors joining writers on strike? How the Screen Actors Guild ended up here.

Extract from ABC News 

ABC News Homepage


The last time Hollywood actors and screenwriters went on strike at the same time, Marilyn Monroe and Elizabeth Taylor were among its biggest stars.

Their films were temporarily halted, while the actors' union – led by Ronald Reagan, two decades before he became the US president – hammered out an agreement with studios.

Back then, performers were fighting for what are known as "residuals" — payments made to actors when their films were later broadcast on television.

Residuals became commonplace over the more than 60 years that followed, but streaming services have now up-ended the way they're paid.

Actors and writers are also grappling with a very modern challenge, warning they face an "existential threat" from artificial intelligence (AI).

Studios argue they have offered historic pay increases and "groundbreaking" AI protections, and that the strike will hurt thousands of other people who depend on the industry. 

But after weeks of failed negotiations, performers rejected their latest proposal and decided to walk off the job.

Why are actors going on strike?

Fran Drescher in black velvet tracksuit and Meredith Stiehm in blue T smile while holding protest signs
Fran Drescher (right), as president of SAG-AFTRA, supported the Writers Guild strikes in May.  (AP Photo: Chris Pizzello)

Actors are represented by the union SAG-AFTRA, which is now led Fran Drescher, the star of 90s sitcom The Nanny.

"The entire business model has been changed by streaming, digital, AI," she told a press conference in Los Angeles.

"This is a moment of history, it is a moment of truth.

"If we don't stand tall right now, we are all going to be in trouble."

The union is demanding increases to base pay and residuals, arguing compensation over the past decade had been "severely eroded by the rise of the streaming ecosystem".

Kylie Sparks, who has spent 20 years in the industry after starting as a child actor, described residuals as being similar to royalty payments.

"Basically every time something re-airs, it triggers a residual cheque, or a movie does well and it triggers," they told the ABC.

"Same thing for DVD, so you'll get a percentage of your pay from DVD or digital buying, like if you buy from iTunes."

Actors argue streaming services pay much lower residuals than TV networks, while Sparks said they would not receive any at all from their work in the recent Netflix comedy I Think You Should Leave.

"Meanwhile, the other day I got a cheque for about $500 from an arc I did on Desperate Housewives in 2008," they said.

"So the fact that I am still making money from a show I did in 2008, but yet I won't see a dime from a show that has been watched millions of hours that came out in May, is unacceptable."

A headshot from a young actor with cropped blonde hair and wire-rimmed glasses
Kylie Sparks said they continue to receive residual cheques from Desperate Housewives, but rarely receive anything for more recent work.  (Supplied: Kylie Sparks)

The rise of generative AI is another major concern, with actors worried about how their voice and likeness could be used without payment, or their consent.

Some fear AI will replace both background extras and post-production jobs, such as re-recording dialogue, that actors would normally be paid for.

LA-based Australian actor Zac Garred believed writers were in a "more precarious" position amid fears scriptwriting could be outsourced to AI tools.

A young blonde man in a white t-shirt
Zac Garred says he fears AI is a threat to both actors and writers.  (Supplied: Zac Garred)

But he said there were still a lot of unknowns for performers, too.

"We know that AI can write songs as Beyonce, we know that we can create a young Harrison Ford," he said, referring to the star's latest Indiana Jones film.

"Now that was with the consent [of Harrison Ford].

"The issue is the vast majority of working actors that make up around about 98 per cent of the union, and where our likenesses would be utilised with or without our consent."

What does the strike mean for your favourite movies and TV shows?

The 11,500 members of the Writers Guild of America have been on strike since May over similar concerns raised by actors.

The writers' strike has already led to major disruptions, with late-night shows like Saturday Night Live forced into running repeats and production paused on upcoming seasons of Abbott Elementary and Stranger Things.

Others, such as showrunner Ryan Murphy's series American Horror Story, kept filming, leading to protests outside.

But with actors now joining writers on the picket lines, most of the industry is expected to grind to a halt.

While some production work will continue, filming will cease and stars will stop promoting their TV shows and movies.

Margot Robbie and Ryan Gosling
During a strike, the Screen Actors Guild bars members from attending premieres, so the Barbie fashion tour is officially over. (Reuters: Maja Smiejkowska)

Pop culture event Comic-Con is expected to be scaled back, and actors are unlikely to attend film festivals.

Overseas TV and film productions could also be affected.

The writers' strike was recently cited as a reason for shutting down one of the largest productions ever planned for Australia, a TV series named Metropolis to be shot in Melbourne. 

The Media, Entertainment and Arts Alliance (MEAA) in Australia said it fully supported the action being taken in the US. 

"A small number of productions currently underway in Australia may be impacted by the SAG-AFTRA and Writers Guild of America strikes," MEAA chief executive Erin Madeleines said in a statement. 

"MEAA representatives are in dialogue with the producers of those productions and will advise crew and performer members of their rights if work is interrupted by the strikes."

The actors' industrial action doesn't officially start until midnight LA time, but the impact of the decision was immediate, with Emily Blunt and Cillian Murphy leaving the London premiere of their upcoming blockbuster, Oppenheimer.

Studios say they're "deeply disappointed" with the decision to strike, arguing they had proposed the highest percentage increases in minimum pay levels in 35 years, among other changes.

"This is the union's choice, not ours," the Alliance of Motion Picture and Television Producers said in a statement. 

"Rather than continuing to negotiate, SAG-AFTRA has put us on a course that will deepen the financial hardship for thousands who depend on the industry for their livelihoods."

Disney CEO Bob Iger accused writers and actors of holding unrealistic expectations, arguing the strike would have a "very damaging" effect on the industry as a whole.

"It's very disturbing to me," he told CNBC in an interview marking the extension of his contract.

"We've talked about disruptive forces on this business and all the challenges we're facing [in] the recovery from COVID, which is ongoing, it's not completely back.

"This is the worst time in the world to add to that disruption."

What happens next?

Some of Hollywood's biggest names have previously voiced their support for SAG-AFTRA's demands, so we could soon see them joining picket lines in a show of solidarity.

The decision has raised questions about this year's Emmys, a day after nominations were announced.

And with no clear sign yet of how long the industrial action could last, studio bosses say it is difficult to predict when consumers will start to notice the impact on their content.

"At least through the end of 2023, we're OK," HBO's CEO Casey Bloys told Variety.

"And then into '24 it starts to get dicier."

While many may have little sympathy for Hollywood's most famous and best-paid names, actors argue they are fighting a battle bigger than themselves.

"What's happening to us is happening across all fields of labour," Drescher said.

"When I did The Nanny, everybody was part of the gravy train. Now it's a walled-in vacuum."

A woman looks at her phone
The Black Mirror episode Joan Is Awful has become the unlikely symbol of the Screen Actor's Guild strike. (Supplied: Netflix)

No comments:

Post a Comment