Future reform of the public broadcaster should consider fresh processes for more independent decision making and transparency

The allegation of direct political interference in the employment of an ABC journalist is very concerning because it warns us that some of our significant national leaders have forgotten the principles of good governance in an open democracy.
In Australian democracy we expect heated and often hostile political debate as our elected representatives battle to promote their priorities for public policy. Fair and factual reporting of these ideas is the job of professional journalists who we expect to keep us informed about our options.         
But it is not the role of journalists to favour government or opposition or any other political representative. Already we know that much media reporting will focus on the government of the day because it is responsible for immediate policy decisions. It is then the media’s role to ensure that scrutiny and public debate follows to test the viability of specific policy announcements. At all times the information provided should be clearly defined as fact or opinion.
This week Australians have seen worrying warning signs that these assumptions about our democracy are being challenged.
Firstly, in terminating Michelle Guthrie as ABC managing director, the board included her leadership style and capacity to work with the federal government.

"The ABC is valued and respected for battling against the odds to maintain independent journalism"

No doubt ABC board members have internal knowledge about this performance area and it is up to them to exercise judgement. However, the relationship between a managing director of the independent national broadcaster and the government is much more complex and needs some elaboration.
The ABC is responsible to the people of Australia, so a managing director needs a strong working relationship with viewers and listeners in providing national programming and services. The second priority is an absolute loyalty and commitment to staff on whom the ABC relies.